An agent who has sold a brand’s products in a region for years: when the contract ends, can it claim something for the customer base it built? If a foreign manufacturer wrote its own law and arbitration abroad into the contract, does that right disappear? This article starts from agency (wakala) in the Majalla, then covers the agency contract and the agent’s indemnity (denkleştirme) under the Turkish Commercial Code, the English commercial agents regime and how the issue plays out in arbitration.
The Majalla: wakala and trading on behalf of others
The eleventh book of the Majalla is devoted to agency (Kitab al-Wakala). Agency is a person entrusting a matter of theirs to another and putting that other person in their place for it (Article 1449). The Majalla distinguishes gratuitous agency from agency for a fee; a person who takes on agency for a fee is held to perform the task undertaken.
In classical law, agents who regularly bought and sold for a merchant and brokers (dallal) who arranged deals were the historical forerunners of today’s commercial agent. The Majalla, however, provides no separate payment for the customer base an agent built when the agency ends. That gap was filled only when modern commercial law recognised the economic value of a continuing intermediary relationship.
Turkish law: agency and indemnity under the TCC
- Definition (TCC Art. 102): an agent is a person who, without a dependent status such as commercial representative, commercial proxy, sales clerk or employee of the business, undertakes on a contractual and continuing basis, in a given place or region, to arrange contracts concerning a commercial business or to conclude them on its behalf. Continuity and independence are the core elements of the definition.
- Termination (TCC Art. 121): either party may terminate an agency contract of indefinite duration with three months’ notice. Even a fixed-term contract may be terminated at any time for just cause.
- Indemnity (TCC Art. 122): after the contract ends, if the principal continues to derive substantial benefits from new customers the agent brought in, and payment is equitable, the agent may claim an appropriate indemnity. The cap is the average annual commission or other payments the agent received over its last five years of activity; if the relationship was shorter, the average for that period applies.
- When no claim arises: no indemnity is due if the principal justifiably terminated the contract because of the agent’s culpable conduct. In Court of Cassation practice, no indemnity arises either where the principal is left with no substantial benefit after termination.
- No advance waiver; time limit: the indemnity right cannot be waived in advance. It must be asserted within one year of the end of the contract.
- Distributors and dealers: Article 122 also applies, unless inequitable, to other continuing relationships granting exclusivity, such as exclusive distribution contracts. Distributors and dealers with regional exclusivity may therefore also claim an indemnity.
In practice, disputes centre on four points: whether the relationship really is agency or an exclusive distribution relationship, whether termination was for just cause, proving the principal’s remaining benefit through customer lists and sales data, and missing the one-year deadline. For penalty clauses attached to post-termination obligations, see our article on penalty clauses.
The English law view: the Commercial Agents Regulations 1993
In England, commercial agents are protected by the Commercial Agents (Council Directive) Regulations 1993, which implemented EU Directive 86/653. For independent agents negotiating the sale of goods, the Regulations offer two options on termination: an “indemnity”, similar to the Turkish model and capped at one year’s commission, or “compensation”, which applies by default and has no cap (reg. 17). These rights do not arise where the principal terminates immediately because of the agent’s default (reg. 18).
- Lonsdale v Howard & Hallam Ltd [2007] UKHL 32: the agency ended when the shoe manufacturer ceased trading, and the agent’s commission had fallen markedly in the final years. The House of Lords held that compensation is calculated by reference to the value of the agency at the date of termination, that is, the value at that date of the income stream it would have generated had it continued. An agency for a declining business is valued accordingly lower.
- Ingmar GB Ltd v Eaton Leonard Technologies Inc (C-381/98, 2000): the Court of Justice held that the Directive’s indemnity and compensation provisions are mandatory, and that where the agent operates in the EU, the principal’s location outside the EU and a choice of non-EU law cannot remove that protection.
Comparison: Turkish law has a single indemnity model capped by the five-year average; English law applies uncapped compensation, measured by the market value of the relationship, unless the contract chooses the indemnity. Both systems prevent advance exclusion of the right and remove it where the agent was at fault.
Examples from arbitration: choice of law and mandatory rules
- Accentuate Ltd v Asigra Inc [2009] EWHC 2655 (QB): the contract between a Canadian software company and an English distributor was governed by Ontario law, with arbitration in Toronto. The tribunal held that compensation under the 1993 Regulations was unavailable because Ontario law applied. In the distributor’s English proceedings, the High Court (Tugendhat J, 30 October 2009) held that Ingmar applies not only to a choice of law but also to an arbitration clause providing for a place and a law that would not give effect to mandatory EU law. It found the clause “null and void” and “inoperative” insofar as it required questions under reg. 17 to be arbitrated, and lifted the stay of proceedings.
- Recognition of an ICC award in Portugal: in a Paris-seated ICC arbitration, the tribunal awarded a distributor damages for loss of future revenue but rejected its claim for goodwill compensation. The losing party argued that this refusal breached Portuguese public policy. The Lisbon Court of Appeal held that refusing goodwill compensation did not breach international public policy, and recognised and ordered enforcement of the award.
The two examples show two outcomes for the same problem: in some legal systems agent protection is a mandatory rule strong enough to limit even an arbitration clause, while in another country it may not be treated as a public policy bar when a foreign award is recognised. For agents in Türkiye and their foreign principals, the lesson is that the governing law and seat of arbitration written into the contract can directly decide the fate of the indemnity right, and should be considered when the contract is made.
Frequently asked questions
The contract says “no indemnity shall be claimed”; is that binding? No. Under Article 122, the indemnity right cannot be waived in advance. A settlement or release made after the contract ends is assessed separately.
I am a distributor, not an agent. Can I still claim? In a continuing distribution relationship with regional or customer exclusivity, Article 122 applies unless that would be inequitable.
How much can be claimed? The cap is the average annual commission or other payments over the last five years. It is a ceiling; the actual amount depends on the principal’s remaining benefit and equity.
Is there a deadline? Yes. The claim must be made within one year of the end of the contract.
More from the Majalla Series
- Hidden Defects and the Status Quo
- Article 17 of the Mecelle
- Article 5 of the Mecelle
- Article 20 of the Mecelle
- Causation in Tort Law
- Majalla Articles 36–45
- Presence, Absence, and Warranty
- Rent Adjustment in Türkiye and Majalla Article 17
- Buying a Defective Car in Türkiye
- Penalty Clauses in Türkiye
- Notice of Defects in Commercial Sales in Türkiye
- Suretyship and Guarantees in Türkiye
- Assignment of Receivables in Türkiye
- Gross Disparity in Turkish Law
- Simple Partnerships in Türkiye
For general information only; not legal advice. Whether an indemnity is due, and how much, depends on the contract and the facts. Sources: Majalla, Book of Wakala, Art. 1449 (as reported in secondary sources); Turkish Commercial Code Arts. 102, 121, 122; Commercial Agents (Council Directive) Regulations 1993, regs. 17–18; Directive 86/653/EEC; Lonsdale v Howard & Hallam Ltd [2007] UKHL 32; Ingmar GB Ltd v Eaton Leonard Technologies Inc (C-381/98); Accentuate Ltd v Asigra Inc [2009] EWHC 2655 (QB); Lisbon Court of Appeal decision recognising an ICC award (as reported on the Kluwer Arbitration Blog).