The factory building was not finished on the promised date, installation of a production line dragged on for months, a software project missed its delivery date. When can the employer terminate, how does it preserve its delay penalty, and what happens when the contractor says “the delay was your fault”? This article starts from the Majalla’s contract of manufacture (istisna’), then covers delay in contracts for work under Turkish law, delay penalties, the English prevention principle and extension-of-time rules, and an arbitration example.
The Majalla: the istisna’ contract
The Majalla defines istisna’ as a contract with a craftsman to make something, giving examples such as making shoes, boats, ships and rifles (Article 388). The rules on istisna’ are in Articles 388–392. Following Imam Abu Yusuf, the Majalla treats istisna’ as binding: if the ordered item is made to the agreed description, neither party may withdraw, and the price need not be paid in advance.
What the Majalla stresses for istisna’ is that the characteristics and dimensions of the work be clearly fixed at the outset; work that does not match the description does not bind the buyer. In today’s contract for work, the same need appears as the requirement to set out clearly the completion date, milestones and the consequences of delay.
Turkish law: delay in contracts for work
- Termination before the completion date (TCO Art. 473/1): if the contractor fails to start on time, delays the work contrary to the contract, or, for reasons not attributable to the employer, falls so far behind that it is clear the work cannot be finished on time, the employer may withdraw from the contract without waiting for the completion date. In practice, it is debated whether this withdrawal operates only prospectively where most of the building is complete.
- General default rules: once the completion date has passed, the employer may give the contractor a reasonable period and then choose between performance plus delay damages, damages instead of performance, or withdrawal (TCO Arts. 123–125). The notice and grace-period requirements must be observed.
- Delay penalty (TCO Art. 179/2): where a penalty is agreed for failure to perform at the agreed time or place, the employer may claim both performance and the penalty, unless it has expressly waived its rights or accepted performance without reservation. In practice, it is therefore crucial to reserve the penalty in writing when taking over the work.
- Reduction and merchants: the court reduces an excessive penalty of its own motion (TCO Art. 182). A debtor who is a merchant, however, cannot ask for reduction on the ground that the penalty is excessive (TCC Art. 22); see our article on penalty clauses.
- Delay caused by the employer: if delay results from late drawings, permits, materials or payments from the employer, the contractor is not in default and no delay penalty is due for that period. Timely written notice of such events is decisive in any later extension-of-time dispute.
In practice, most delay disputes turn on proving who is responsible for which delay. The programme, site diary, payment correspondence and extension requests are the core material for the court-appointed expert. Where delays partly overlap (concurrent delay), allocating responsibility is among the hardest questions unless the contract says how to do it.
The English law view: the prevention principle and extensions of time
Under English construction law, an employer cannot claim liquidated damages from the contractor for delay it caused itself. Under this “prevention principle”, if the contract has no extension-of-time mechanism for employer-caused delay, the completion date may fall away and time become “at large”.
- Peak Construction (Liverpool) Ltd v McKinney Foundations Ltd (1970) 1 BLR 111: the Court of Appeal held that an employer could not claim the contractual liquidated damages for delay it had partly caused. The case is cited as the classic source of the prevention principle.
- Multiplex Constructions (UK) Ltd v Honeywell Control Systems Ltd (No 2) [2007] EWHC 447 (TCC): Jackson J held that where the contract provides an extension of time for the employer’s acts of prevention, those acts do not set time at large. The contractor had to claim its extension under the contractual procedure.
- North Midland Building Ltd v Cyden Homes Ltd [2018] EWCA Civ 1744: the contract expressly provided that concurrent delay would not count towards an extension of time. The Court of Appeal held that the prevention principle is an implied rule that applies only where the parties have not agreed otherwise, and upheld the express term.
- Triple Point Technology Inc v PTT Public Company Ltd [2021] UKSC 29: the contract was terminated before the work was ever completed. The Supreme Court held that liquidated damages continue to accrue up to the date of termination.
Comparison: under Turkish law, delay caused by the employer removes the contractor’s default and the related penalty, but there is no detailed statutory extension-of-time mechanism and the outcome depends heavily on the contract and the evidence. In English law, the contract’s extension-of-time and notice provisions are central: a well-drafted extension clause stops the prevention principle from working against the employer.
An example from international arbitration
- A FIDIC infrastructure project in Romania (ICC arbitrations): the dispute ran for about ten years and produced six Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) decisions and four ICC awards. The first ICC award granted the contractor a seven-month extension of time and additional cost for employer’s risk events; a later award granted a further nine months. The contractor then sought a pro rata reduction of delay damages for parts of the works already in use. The arbitrator held that the contractual claim could not be examined on the merits because the contractor had not given a timely notice of dissatisfaction with the relevant DAB decision; but, relying on the penalty-reduction rule of the applicable Romanian law, reduced the delay damages to reflect partial performance.
The series shows that delay disputes on large projects rarely end with a single decision, and that missing contractual notice periods can have serious consequences. It also shows that a penalty-reduction rule in the governing law can affect the outcome despite contractual limits. In FIDIC contracts governed by Turkish law, notice periods likewise have to be read together with the penalty rules of the Turkish Code of Obligations and Commercial Code.
Frequently asked questions
Can I terminate before the completion date? Yes. If the contractor has not started on time, or it is clear from progress that the work cannot be finished on time, TCO Art. 473/1 allows it.
I have taken over the work; can I still claim the delay penalty? If you accepted the work without reservation, the right to the penalty is at risk (TCO Art. 179/2). The reservation should be written into the handover record or a separate letter.
What if part of the delay was caused by the employer? No delay penalty is due for the period caused by the employer. The rest depends on how well events are documented and on the contract’s extension-of-time provisions.
We are a merchant; can an excessive delay penalty be reduced? Under TCC Art. 22, a merchant debtor cannot seek reduction on the ground that the penalty is excessive. Exceptional cases where the penalty would ruin the debtor economically are considered separately in Court of Cassation practice.
For general information only; not legal advice. The consequences of delay depend on the contract and the facts. Sources: Majalla Arts. 388–392 (as reported in secondary sources); Turkish Code of Obligations Arts. 123–125, 179, 182, 473; Turkish Commercial Code Art. 22; Peak Construction (Liverpool) Ltd v McKinney Foundations Ltd (1970) 1 BLR 111; Multiplex Constructions (UK) Ltd v Honeywell Control Systems Ltd (No 2) [2007] EWHC 447 (TCC); North Midland Building Ltd v Cyden Homes Ltd [2018] EWCA Civ 1744; Triple Point Technology Inc v PTT Public Company Ltd [2021] UKSC 29; Romanian FIDIC/ICC series of awards (as reported on the Kluwer Arbitration Blog, 26 September 2017).