Lesotho Highlands v Impregilo [2005] UKHL 43: Is an error of law an excess of power?

A dispute over a dam in Lesotho produced the leading English authority on when an award can be set aside for “excess of powers”. The arbitrators had expressed the award in currencies the contract did not provide for. The House of Lords held that even if they were wrong, that was not an excess of power.

Case details

  • Case: Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Impregilo SpA and others [2005] UKHL 43, [2006] 1 AC 221
  • Court: House of Lords; leading speech by Lord Steyn
  • Date: 30 June 2005
  • Earlier stage: [2003] EWCA Civ 1159 (the Court of Appeal had upheld the challenge on the currency point)
  • Arbitration: ICC Rules, seat in London; contract governed by the law of Lesotho
  • Statute: Arbitration Act 1996 s.48(4) and s.68(2)(b)

The ruling in one sentence: an erroneous exercise of a power the tribunal has is not the exercise of a power it does not have; an error of law, however clear, is not an excess of power under s.68(2)(b) of the 1996 Act.

What was the dispute?

A public authority in Lesotho engaged a consortium of seven companies from various countries to build a dam. The contract was governed by the law of Lesotho, the currency of account was the Maloti, and payments were to be converted into the contractors’ currencies at exchange rates fixed on a specified date. The project was completed and claims for increased costs went to ICC arbitration. The tribunal found that 18.9 million Maloti should have been paid. Because the Maloti had fallen heavily by the date of the award, the tribunal, relying on s.48(4) of the 1996 Act, ordered payment in the contractors’ own currencies at the contractual rates. The judge and the Court of Appeal treated this as an excess of power.

Key passages

“But the issue was whether the tribunal “exceeded its powers” within the meaning of section 68(2)(b). This required the courts below to address the question whether the tribunal purported to exercise a power which it did not have or whether it erroneously exercised a power that it did have. If it is merely a case of erroneous exercise of power vesting in the tribunal no excess of power under section 68(2)(b) is involved.”

Lord Steyn, para. 24

“In making this general observation it must always be borne in mind that the erroneous exercise of an available power cannot by itself amount to an excess of power. A mere error of law will not amount to an excess of power under section 68(2)(b).”

Lord Steyn, para. 32

Lord Steyn recalled that the 1996 Act leaves the court only “essential” powers (para. 18), and observed that treating an error of law as an excess of jurisdiction has overtones of the public law doctrine in Anisminic, whereas the court’s powers in arbitration law are quite different (para. 25). The appeal was allowed, the order remitting the award was set aside and the employer’s application was dismissed.

Why it matters

  • Finality: setting aside a London award for “excess of powers” became exceptional. English courts apply Lesotho routinely to s.68 challenges.
  • Currency risk: long-term construction contracts should state the currency of account, the currency of payment and the conversion date. If the parties do not want the tribunal to have a general power such as s.48(4), they must agree that in writing.
  • Challenge strategy: repackaging an error of law as an “excess of power” does not work. A separate route for errors of law (s.69) exists only where the parties have not excluded it and its conditions are met.

The view from Türkiye

Turkish law takes the same approach. Under Article 15 of Türkiye’s International Arbitration Law (Law No. 4686), the only recourse against an award is an action for annulment on limited grounds; in domestic arbitration, Article 439 of the Code of Civil Procedure plays the same role. The Court of Cassation holds that the merits of an award cannot be reviewed for legal correctness in annulment proceedings. Public policy and non-arbitrability are considered by the court of its own motion, but they are not a general gateway for reviewing errors of law on the merits. In foreign-currency construction contracts with contractors from Türkiye, clear currency and exchange rate clauses prevent outcomes that are hard to correct later through annulment.

Frequently asked questions

The tribunal plainly misread the contract. Can the award be set aside? In English law, as a rule, no: an error of interpretation is not an excess of power. In Turkish law, too, annulment is not a review of the merits and is available only on limited grounds.

Can a tribunal award payment in a currency the contract does not mention? In English law, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing, s.48(4) allows the tribunal to order payment in any currency. Even a wrong use of that power was not an excess of power in Lesotho.

For general information only; not legal advice. Sources: Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Impregilo SpA [2005] UKHL 43, [2006] 1 AC 221, paragraphs 18 and 22-32 as set out in later English judgments ([2021] EWHC 3301 (Comm), [2024] EWHC 1032 (TCC), [2014] EWHC 1348 (Comm); caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk); [2003] EWCA Civ 1159; Arbitration Act 1996 ss.48, 68, 69; Law No. 4686 on International Arbitration, Art. 15; Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100), Art. 439; case summaries in published legal commentary.

Paylaş
LinkedIn X WhatsApp E-posta