Salini v Morocco (ICSID ARB/00/4): When is a construction contract an investment?

A motorway built in Morocco by two Italian contractors raised one of the basic questions of investment arbitration: is a construction contract an “investment”? The criteria the ICSID tribunal listed in this decision are debated worldwide today as the “Salini test”.

Case details

  • Case: Salini Costruttori S.p.A. and Italstrade S.p.A. v Kingdom of Morocco, ICSID Case No. ARB/00/4, Decision on Jurisdiction
  • Date: 23 July 2001
  • Tribunal: Robert Briner (President), Ibrahim Fadlallah, Bernardo Cremades
  • Basis: Italy-Morocco bilateral investment treaty and Article 25 of the ICSID Convention
  • Project: a section of the Rabat-Fes motorway; employer ADM, Morocco’s state-controlled motorway company; contract of 1994
  • Reported: 42 ILM 609 (2003)

The ruling in one sentence: a construction contract can be an investment under Article 25 of the ICSID Convention where it involves contributions, a certain duration, a sharing of risk and a contribution to the host state’s economic development; to reach ICSID, a claimant must satisfy both the treaty’s definition of investment and that of the Convention.

What was the dispute?

In 1994 Salini and Italstrade contracted with ADM, Morocco’s state-controlled motorway company, to build a section of the Rabat-Fes motorway. After completion, the contractors’ claims were rejected in full by the employer’s engineer. In 2000 the companies brought an ICSID claim under the Italy-Morocco investment treaty. Morocco objected to jurisdiction, arguing that the contract gave jurisdiction to the administrative courts of Rabat and that the contractors had waived the ICSID route; whether a construction contract could be an investment was also in issue.

Key passages

“The doctrine generally considers that investment infers: contributions, a certain duration of performance of the contract and a participation in the risks of the transaction … In reading the Convention’s preamble, one may add the contribution to the economic development of the host State of the investment as an additional condition.”

Para. 52

The tribunal held that in a treaty claim brought through ICSID the investment must satisfy both the treaty definition and Article 25 of the Convention. Later decisions call this the “double keyhole” test.

Why it matters

  • Construction projects can qualify: after Salini, major infrastructure and construction projects came to be seen as capable of treaty protection where the conditions are met.
  • The status of the criteria is disputed: some ICSID tribunals have applied the Salini criteria as mandatory jurisdictional requirements, others as non-binding indicators. The economic development criterion is particularly contested. An English court said in 2017 that it preferred the second view.
  • A double check: an investor heading to ICSID should be ready to show an investment under Article 25, not just under the treaty’s broad definition.

The view from Türkiye

For contractors from Türkiye building motorways, bridges, dams and power plants abroad, Salini is a basic reference point. Türkiye is a party to the ICSID Convention, and most of its investment treaties provide for ICSID arbitration. In Bayındır v Pakistan, covered earlier in this series, an ICSID tribunal also treated a Turkish contractor’s motorway contract as an investment. Documenting the contribution, duration and allocation of risk when entering a project makes it easier to prove investment status later.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Salini test applied in every ICSID case? No. Some tribunals treat the criteria as mandatory, others apply them flexibly. The outcome can depend on the tribunal’s approach and the treaty’s definition.

Can a contractor go to ICSID if the contract names a local court? Morocco raised this objection in Salini. Many ICSID decisions treat the contractual forum clause and the treaty’s ICSID clause as separate routes protecting different claims. Which claim belongs where is assessed case by case.

For general information only; not legal advice. Sources: Salini Costruttori S.p.A. and Italstrade S.p.A. v Kingdom of Morocco, ICSID Case No. ARB/00/4, Decision on Jurisdiction (23 July 2001), 42 ILM 609 (2003); paragraph 52 as set out in later English judgments ([2016] EWHC 153 (Comm); see also [2017] EWHC 2889 (Ch), [2024] EWHC 2102 (Comm); caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk); ICSID Convention, Art. 25; case summaries in published legal commentary.

Paylaş
LinkedIn X WhatsApp E-posta